18th on the Bay
The condo buildings on 18th Boulevard — lock-and-leave living beside the course's closing stretch. Condos carry a separate condo fee as well.
Nearly 800 gated acres on the Indian River Bay — and the agent showing it to you lives behind the gate.
Dane Baich lives in The Peninsula now. It is his current country-club community and, by his own description, his final one. He has sold homes here for years and has been playing the golf course since it was built. If you want to know what life inside the gate is actually like, start with someone who lives it.
Buying in, or already here and thinking about your next move inside the gate? Either way, it starts with a conversation — 302-588-9278.
A gated community on the Indian River Bay in Millsboro, Delaware — nearly 800 acres of golf, water, and preserved land, with Lewes and Rehoboth Beach about 13 miles away and the bay in your backyard.
Dane's verdict, after playing and selling here for years: the amenities are second to none in Delaware. Here is what a day inside the gate can hold.
The golf
Delaware's first private Jack Nicklaus Signature course — opened 2006, par 72, 7,302 yards — with seven holes along the Indian River Bay and Lingo Creek. Dane has played it since the day it opened.
The clubhouse
Terrace Grille dining, a wine room, billiards, lounges, a pro shop, driving range and putting greens, and bocce courts — the social center of the community.
Lakeside Village
Five pools — indoor, adults-only heated, a multipurpose activity pool, a sandy-beach wave pool, and a kids' pool — plus the Lakeside Grille, miniature golf, and the Athletic Club with its fitness center and spa.
The water & the land
A private bay beach with a pier, boat launch and kayak access, a Nature & Exploration Center, and miles of trails through preserved nature areas.
The rest of the day
Tennis and pickleball courts, a dog park, and a community garden. Club membership is required and comes in three levels — Social, Sports, and Reserve.
The setting
Lewes and Rehoboth Beach are about 13 miles away — close enough for dinner, far enough that the gate closes behind you at the end of the night.
The Peninsula is not one community — it is ten, and they do not live alike or carry alike. Condos for lock-and-leave living, villas and townhomes, single-family sections, and a custom enclave. The quarterly Peninsula HOA under each name is from the community's 2026 fee sheet; condos carry a second, separate condo fee on top.
The condo buildings on 18th Boulevard — lock-and-leave living beside the course's closing stretch. Condos carry a separate condo fee as well.
The condo community on Windswept Drive — the simplest way in, at the lowest quarterly HOA on the fee sheet.
Villas and townhomes around the marina basin, with custom homes in the mix.
One community spanning condos, villas, and custom homes — including one of the newest single-family sections in the community.
Single-family homes on golf-course lots.
The custom, luxury enclave — and the highest quarterly HOA in the community.
Schell Brothers' final community — the last new construction in The Peninsula.
Villas and townhomes in one of the community's quieter sections.
Around Lakeside Village — the pools, the Athletic Club, and the Lakeside Grille are this community's front yard.
One of the community's established residential communities, inside the gate.
Which one fits depends on how you will actually live here — full-time or lock-and-leave, golf-first or pool-first, new construction or resale. That is a conversation Dane has from inside the community, not from a brochure. Ask him about a community.
What's for sale inside the community right now — Dane's own Peninsula listing first, then the full live list.
Dane's listing · Featured
$389,000
View this home →Property information provided by Bright MLS. © 2026 Bright MLS.
The Peninsula's costs come in layers, and the layers vary by community — anyone who quotes you one community-wide number is guessing. These are the layers, from the community's 2026 fee sheet.
Layer one · Every home
Billed quarterly and set by your community and home type. It covers the 24/7 manned gate and security, the Nature & Exploration Center, the bay beach and fishing pier, trails, roads, snow removal, lighting, landscaping care, and trash collection — and it includes Verizon FiOS internet and television ($60.20 a month of the total).
Layer two · Condos
Condos carry a second fee to their own association, on top of the HOA — in the 18th on the Bay condos it runs $1,409 to $2,228 per quarter, based on the size of the home. It is the layer buyers most often miss, and the first one Dane checks on any condo.
Layer three · Every home
A fraction of what the same home would cost to carry in New Jersey, Pennsylvania, or New York — the tax picture is a large part of why people land here. See the comparison.
At purchase · One-time
Every sale pays a capital contribution to the Peninsula Community Association of ½ of 1% of the purchase price — that layer is the same on every sale. A second capital fee goes to your community association and varies: $1,250 in Windswept, $750 in several communities, $225–$600 in others (some on new sales only), another ½ of 1% in the 18th on the Bay condos — and none at all in Lakeside, Sanctuary, and the custom sections.
Club membership is required at The Peninsula, and it's the question every buyer asks first. Here are the three tiers side by side, with the club's current 2026 pricing — so you can see exactly what each level gets you.
Social
The social core
For dining, pools & fitness — the everyday club life, without golf or racquet sports.
One-time initiation fee
$386 / month dues · $4,632 / year
$800 / year food minimum
Sports
Adds racquets + pay-as-you-play golf
Everything in Social, plus tennis, pickleball, and access to the Nicklaus course when you want to play.
One-time initiation fee
$457 / month dues · $5,484 / year
Planning to rent your property out? Sports is the minimum — renting requires at least this tier.
$800 / year food minimum
Reserve
The full Peninsula lifestyle
The top tier — access to every amenity and every event the club offers, with full golf privileges.
One-time initiation fee
$775 / month dues · $9,300 / year
$800 / year food minimum
Pricing from The Peninsula's 2026 fee schedule: non-refundable membership initiation fees as of January 16, 2026, and monthly dues as of January 10, 2026. Tier descriptions are from The Peninsula Golf & Country Club. Fees and membership terms are set by the club and are subject to change — please confirm current details with the club's membership director before purchase.
Search everything currently for sale inside the gate — condos, villas, townhomes, single-family homes, and the last new construction in Still Waters.
Search Peninsula homes Call Dane — 302-588-9278
Featured listing
Dane's current listing inside the community is the condo at 27270 18th Boulevard in 18th on the Bay — the same community whose carrying costs are worked through above. Its dedicated listing site carries the full photo tour, floor details, and showing information.
Plenty of Peninsula moves never leave the community — a condo owner who wants a single-family home, a big house that has become more house than needed. Dane lives here and sells here, so he knows what each community trades for and who is quietly looking. If your next move is inside the gate, start with the same conversation.
Sussex County property taxes are a fraction of what the surrounding states charge, with no sales tax on top — one more layer of the carrying-cost picture, and the friendliest one.
The questions buyers ask first about life inside the gate.
Yes — club membership is required, and it comes in three tiers: Social, with a $20,000 initiation fee and dues of $386 a month; Sports, at $35,000 and $457 a month; and Reserve, at $70,000 and $775 a month. Each tier carries an $800 annual food minimum.
The Peninsula HOA runs from $822 to $1,218 per quarter, set by your community and home type. Condo owners also pay a separate condo fee — in the 18th on the Bay condos, it runs $1,409 to $2,228 per quarter.
Yes — renting out a Peninsula property is available to members at the Sports tier or above. Sports membership adds tennis and pickleball plus pay-as-you-play access to the golf course.
The Peninsula has ten communities: 18th on the Bay, Windswept, Marina Bay, Sailside, Veranda, Sanctuary, Still Waters, Conservancy, Lakeside, and Moorings. Together they span condos, villas, townhomes, single-family homes, and custom homes.
It is Delaware's first private Jack Nicklaus Signature course — par 72 and 7,302 yards, opened in 2006. Seven of its holes run along the Indian River Bay and Lingo Creek.
Tap to call, or leave your name, one way to reach you, and one question — about a home, a community, the fees, or selling yours. That's all it takes to start.
Dane Baich — REALTOR®, Buyer's Agent
Lee Ann Wilkinson Group
Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices PenFed Realty
Delaware License RS-0015879
He'll get back to you shortly.
Need him sooner? Call or text 302-588-9278.
Send it to [email protected] or text/call 302-588-9278.