New construction + resales
Peninsula Lakes is a community of 656 homes built around 11 lakes, in the Route 24 corridor between Millsboro and Long Neck. Two builders put it up: Ryan Homes built single-family homes here, and Schell Brothers built both single-family homes and twin homes. Clubhouse, lazy-river pool, no gates and no golf — and one thing to clear up first, because everyone asks: it is not part of The Peninsula. It's its own community, and a good one.
Every current listing in the community, straight from the MLS.
Popular searches: Peninsula Lakes · Long Neck · Millsboro 19966 · Schell Brothers homes
Every home currently for sale in Peninsula Lakes, updated from Bright MLS throughout the day.
See every Peninsula Lakes listing →
Property information provided by Bright MLS. © 2026 Bright MLS.
Peninsula Lakes was built around water: 11 lakes thread through the community, and a good share of the homes back up to one. The clubhouse and lazy-river pool are the social center. There's no gate and no golf course — the draw is the lakes and a Route 24 location that runs straight to Lewes and Rehoboth Beach in one direction and Millsboro's Route 113 corridor in the other.
Schell is in its final phases here, so the community is nearly complete: most streets are finished and lived-in, with the last new sections still selling.
The names confuse everyone, so here it is plainly. The Peninsula is the gated, bay-front club community on Indian River Bay — Jack Nicklaus Signature golf, full club membership required, about 1,300 homes. Peninsula Lakes is a separate neighborhood a few miles away: different community, different HOA, no shared amenities, no club membership.
Dane lives in The Peninsula and sells in both. If you're comparing them, the honest short version: The Peninsula is a private club community on the bay; Peninsula Lakes is a lakefront neighborhood without the club — and without the club's costs. Which one fits depends on how you'll actually live here, and he's glad to talk it through.
Buying new from Schell. With final phases selling, the choices narrow to the remaining homesites and quick-delivery homes. Schell's process — selections, options, build timeline — rewards a buyer who knows it; Dane has sold Schell homes for years and knows their reps and procedures.
Two builders, two products. Ryan Homes built single-family homes here — their models (the Winterbrook, the Cumberland, the Savannah) are the Ryan sections of the community. Schell Brothers built single-family homes and the community's twin homes; the twins are Schell's alone. On any resale, which builder built it, and whether it's a twin or a single, is part of pricing it — and Dane has sold homes from both builders.
Buying a resale. The first resales are appearing as the community matures: no build wait, finished lots, and pricing set by the market. On a resale, the homework is the lake: which homes actually sit on water, and what those lots have sold for versus interior lots.
The costs to pin down. HOA dues and what they cover, and any one-time contribution at closing.
Early resales here compete with Schell's final new phases, so the pitch has to be sharp: available now, established lot, priced against the right comparables — lakefront against lakefront. Dane's listing process includes a free staging consultation and a dedicated website for your home.
No — Peninsula Lakes is its own separate community, a few miles from The Peninsula. The Peninsula is the gated, bay-front club community on Indian River Bay, while Peninsula Lakes is a lakefront neighborhood built around 11 lakes.
Peninsula Lakes is a community of 656 homes built by Ryan Homes and Schell Brothers. Ryan Homes built single-family homes, and Schell Brothers built both single-family homes and the community's twin homes.
Peninsula Lakes was built around 11 lakes that thread through the community, and a good share of the homes back up to one. The clubhouse and lazy-river pool are the social center.
Yes — Schell Brothers is in its final phases in Peninsula Lakes, with the last new sections still selling. Most streets are finished and lived-in, and the first resales are also appearing as the community matures.
Peninsula Lakes is served by the Indian River School District. The community sits in the Route 24 corridor between Millsboro and Long Neck.
Call Dane — 302-588-9278 — or send a message below.
Office: 16698 Kings Hwy, Suite A, Lewes, DE
Dane Baich, REALTOR® — Lee Ann Wilkinson Group
Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices PenFed Realty
He'll get back to you shortly.
Need him sooner? Call or text 302-588-9278.
Send it to [email protected] or text/call 302-588-9278.